Lily's Custom
Cookies

Decorated cookies vary in price according to their size and the extent of the design, but generally start from $3.50 each when presented in a bakery box. Writing on the cookie for a name or monogram begins at .25 cents per cookie (please keep in mind that the cookie’s shape and size will limit how much can be written; we may charge more for hand-piping multiple words on the cookie). Add $1 per cookie to have each one individually presented in a cellophane bag with an organza bow.

We are happy to fulfill large orders. Our largest order to date was 2,750 decorated cookies in bags with bows!

Please call us as soon as possible! We may be able to change quantities or specifications of an order if notified within three full business days of the original due date. You will be charged in full for any order cancelled within that three-day period.

We’ll be glad to arrange delivery through a local messenger service at the customer’s expense.

Decorated cookies that will be shipped must be packaged in bags and bows for protection and freshness preservation. We then wrap the bagged cookies in kraft paper to cushion them for shipping and recommend using companies that offer overnight or priority shipping to complete the protective packaging and delivery. For large custom orders (more than three dozen), please call well in advance to discuss your shipment needs, and we’ll see how best to accommodate you.

Yes, we definitely do! However, if you’re extra-sensitive to gluten, be aware that there’s a good deal of flour in our bakery air and you may need to seek out a strictly gluten-free bakery. Also, while we make a number of delicious nut-free cookies, all of our bakery equipment comes into regular contact with peanuts, pecans, walnuts, and the like. If you have a particularly high sensitivity to nuts, we recommend you not consume any of our baked goods (so sorry!).